Keypad Lock vs Smart Lock: Which Fits Your Home?
By Yale Locks | Official Online Store | Yale Home | Published: 2026-10-21
Category: Buying Guides
Deciding between a keypad lock and a smart lock? We compare the Yale Assure Lock Touchscreen and Yale Approach Lock to help you choose based on features, installation, and lifestyle.
Quick answer
Choose a keypad lock if you want a simple, affordable key-free upgrade that works right out of the box. Pick a smart lock if you need remote access, voice control, and integration with your existing smart home system.
What sets them apart
A keypad lock replaces your traditional deadbolt with a touchscreen or button pad. You enter a code to unlock the door, and a tap locks it behind you. There is no app, no Wi-Fi, and no subscription. It is a self-contained upgrade that works the moment you install it.
A smart lock adds connectivity. With built-in Wi-Fi or Bluetooth, you can lock and unlock from your phone, check who comes and goes, and link the lock to your smart home hub or voice assistant. The trade-off is a higher price and the need to manage batteries and network setup.
Installation differences matter
Keypad locks typically replace your entire deadbolt assembly. That means removing your existing lock and installing a new one. The Yale Assure Lock Touchscreen, for example, is a standalone deadbolt that requires a full swap but works with most standard doors.
Smart locks like the Yale Approach Lock are designed as retrofit units. They mount over your existing deadbolt on the inside of the door, so you keep your keys as a backup. The keypad is separate and can be placed anywhere within Bluetooth range. This makes the Approach a good choice for renters or anyone who does not want to modify the door.
How to decide: keypad lock vs smart lock
- Do you want remote access?: If you need to lock or unlock your door from anywhere, or want to let in a guest while you are away, choose a smart lock with Wi-Fi. A keypad lock only works when you are physically at the door.
- Do you rent or own?: Renters often prefer a retrofit smart lock like the Yale Approach Lock because it does not require removing the existing deadbolt. Homeowners can choose either type, but a standalone keypad lock gives a cleaner look and more finish options.
- Do you already use a smart home hub?: If you have Alexa, Google Assistant, or a smart home system, a smart lock can integrate with your routines. A keypad lock works independently and does not connect to other devices. Check whether the smart lock you are considering supports your specific hub before buying.
- What is your budget?: Keypad locks are generally less expensive. The Yale Assure Lock Touchscreen costs about $126. Smart locks with Wi-Fi and biometric features, like the Yale Approach Lock, are priced higher at around $163.
- How important is backup access?: A keypad lock gives you a code and a physical key. A retrofit smart lock like the Approach lets you keep your existing key as a backup, plus you can use the keypad or the app. Decide which fallback method you trust most.
Product facts at a glance
- Yale Approach™ Lock with Wi-Fi and Keypad Touch: The Yale Approach Lock is Yale's first retrofit biometric smart lock. It installs over your existing deadbolt and includes a separate keypad that can be placed anywhere within Bluetooth range. If you rent or do not want to replace your current hardware, this lock gives you smart features without changing the outside of your door.
Yale Approach™ Lock with Wi-Fi and Keypad Touch - Yale Assure Lock Touchscreen, Standalone: The Yale Assure Lock Touchscreen is a standalone keypad deadbolt that lets you unlock with a 4-8 digit code and lock by tapping the keypad. It is a straightforward key-free upgrade that works immediately, no app or network setup required.
Yale Assure Lock Touchscreen, Standalone
Which lock fits your situation?
Best for
- Renters or anyone who cannot modify the door exterior — choose the Yale Approach Lock for its retrofit installation and separate keypad.
- Budget-conscious buyers who want key-free entry without ongoing costs — choose the Yale Assure Lock Touchscreen for its simple, standalone operation.
Not for
- If you need to grant remote access or integrate with a smart home hub, a basic keypad lock will not meet your needs. Upgrade to a smart lock with Wi-Fi.
- If you prefer a single, flush-mounted lock on the door face, a retrofit unit with a separate keypad may not suit your aesthetic. Consider a standalone smart lock instead.
